What is "Allowed" vs. Your Legal Rights in Labor and Birth
When it comes to giving birth, there’s a lot of focus on what you’re “allowed” to do—or more accurately, what you’re supposedly not allowed to do. But here’s the truth: the word “allowed” has no place in birth, and understanding your rights versus hospital policies is key to reclaiming your power in the birthing process.
Understanding Your Basic Rights
First and foremost, let’s talk about your rights as a birthing mother. You have the right to receive full and accurate information about any interventions, including the risks involved and the alternatives available. This isn’t just a courtesy—it’s a legal right. You also have the right to refuse any medical test or procedure, without fear of hostility or retaliation from your care provider. This is your body, and when it comes to your health or the health of your baby, you are the one in charge.
The True Meaning of Informed Consent
One of the most critical concepts in maternity care today is informed consent. Unfortunately, it’s often misunderstood or ignored altogether. True informed consent goes beyond simply signing a form when you arrive at the hospital. It’s a process where you are provided with all the necessary information about a procedure, including its risks and alternatives, so that you can make an informed decision.
Yet, too often, women are subjected to interventions without fully understanding them or even without their explicit consent. This lack of informed consent contributes to a cesarean rate far higher than what is recommended by the World Health Organization. When mothers are knowledgeable and feel empowered to decline unnecessary interventions, the landscape of birth could look very different.
Hospital Consent Forms vs. True Informed Consent
If you’re planning a hospital birth, you’ll likely be asked to sign consent forms as part of the intake process. But let’s be clear: signing these forms is not the same as giving informed consent. A signature on a form does not replace the ongoing conversation that should happen between you and your care provider. Informed consent is your legal right, and it should be an ongoing dialogue, not a one-time checkbox.
The Issue of Maternal-Fetal Conflict
There’s a particularly challenging situation that arises when doctors pressure mothers to accept interventions for the perceived benefit of the baby. This is known as Maternal-Fetal Conflict. Ethically and legally, however, informed consent means that a pregnant woman retains the right to refuse any medical intervention, even if it is recommended for the baby’s health. Despite this, many women still report being treated as though they have no say during their births. This widespread issue reflects deeper, systemic problems within the maternity care system.
The Problem with “Allowed” in Birth
One of the most frustrating aspects of this issue is the use of the word “allowed” by care providers. Who is allowing whom? You are the one hiring your provider, not the other way around. The idea that you need permission to make decisions about your own body during birth is not only outdated but also harmful. The United States is the only developed country with a rising maternal mortality rate, and this is linked to unnecessary interventions and practices that go against evidence-based care.
Women have been led to believe that they have no say in their birthing process, which couldn’t be further from the truth. Whether it’s a VBAC (Vaginal Birth After Cesarean) or another choice, it’s essential to remember that you have the right to make informed decisions about your care.
Hospital Policy vs. Your Rights
Before we wrap up, let’s talk about hospital policies. These policies are often created to ensure a safe environment and to protect the hospital from liability. However, they should not override your right to informed consent. Policies are guidelines, not laws, and they should be flexible enough to allow for individualized care.
If your provider says, “That’s not allowed,” it’s crucial to question this. Ask for clarification, and remind them of your right to informed consent. Don’t let them dictate what you can or cannot do with your own body during birth.
Taking Back Your Authority in Birth
The authority in childbirth always lies with you, the mother, not with your provider. You hold the power in your birth, and it’s time to change the language and dynamics around childbirth to reflect this. When you’re told something isn’t allowed, speak up. Ask questions, and don’t be afraid to assert your rights.
I hope this discussion has brought you clarity about your rights as a birthing mother. Remember, your rights during birth are the same as your rights as a human being. For a deeper dive into these topics, I cover them extensively in my childbirth education course. Join the waitlist now and receive a discount when the doors open. It’s the only childbirth education course you’ll ever need.
Join Wild Beginnings to learn more and take charge of your birthing experience.
